YA Fiction – A Study in Contrasts

by Kym on August 11, 2009

I read a great deal of YA fiction. Partially because I’m currently attempting to write in that genre, but mostly because (on a good day) I have the emotional maturity of an average eighteen year old (no offense to eighteen year olds intended, truly). There’s just something about the struggles and strivings of characters who are on the brink of adulthood. Though technically I’ve long since passed into that realm myself, I still feel hesitant and awkward here. As if at any moment I might be discovered and chucked out, back into the dreadful abyss that was my teenage years.


I’ve often read books centering around “adult” characters, sometimes characters who are younger than I am, but I can’t quite connect. I think it’s that, progression wise, I’m not there yet. Stunted emotional growth aside though, I couldn’t be happier with the literature available to teenagers and teenagers at heart like myself.


Bright Blue Miracle


cover


I met Becca at the LDS Storymaker’s Conference this past Spring. She introduced herself (thank heaven – let us not forget Kim’s stunted-ness) and immediately struck me as sweet, sincere, and intelligent. My first impression has been confirmed and amplified a hundred fold as I’ve read her blog and come to know her a little better. I was nervous to read her book, I’ll confess. It’s one thing to dislike the work of a stranger and another thing entirely to dislike the work of someone you’re tentatively building a friendship with.


Cue relief though, because Bright Blue Miracle was an absolute delight. I even stayed up till, what was it, three in the morning I think, because I couldn’t sleep without finishing. It was an emotional experience, and poor Neil had his sleep disturbed by sudden bursts of laughter and also by me fumbling around for the kleenex box. If you can’t identify with the plight of a teenage girl flung from one potentially devastating crisis to the next, this is not the book for you. It’s intense and moving and all sorts of lovely in between.


I found Bright Blue Miracle to be not only moving, but also uplifting. Though I cannot say the same of this next book, I was nonetheless similarly enthralled. I often notice this contrast in my chosen reading material. Light vs. Dark. Uplifting vs. Unsettling. Each have their merit, but I suppose that’s another blog post altogether.


The Hourglass Door


thehourgassdoormangum


I wish the comparison between this book and Twilight were easier to avoid, but by way of apology to the very talented Lisa Mangum I can say quite fervently that the comparison cannot help but be favourable. Though deliciously flavoured with elements of the supernatural, romance, danger, and suspense of a very intense nature, Mangum has set herself apart as a force to be reckoned with in the YA genre. Her style is compelling and her flair with language was a constant source of delight as I all but devoured the book.


There’s no denying that the romance between the two main characters is one of the central focuses of the book, but the intricacy of the plot prevented (for me) any desire to groan or roll my eyes. There is a believability to the relationship despite the supernatural backdrop to it. A result, I believe, of some very impressive characterization on the author’s part.


Now I’m a self-confessed prude when it comes to the YA genre. Always, in the back of my mind, I’m thinking of my daughters. And I confess that there are books I’ve actually removed from my home in hopes that my daughters won’t read them till they’re old enough to move out. However, despite the intensity of the romantic relationship depicted in this book, I may allow my daughters to read it before they leave home. There is meaning…poignancy, if you will, to what Mangum has created here. Something that is sadly lacking in certain other books in this genre.


Overall, a thoroughly entertaining read and I’m keenly anticipating the release of the next book.

11 comments

Ooh, I love a good book recommendation! Thanks. The second one is even at my library so I put it on my hold list.

I’m also currently in the middle of a Young Adult novel that’s been compared to Twilight but that I’ve been enjoying more (maybe it’s partially that it’s hard for Twilight to live up to the hype?) Stay tuned to my blog for the review; I’ll probably finish it tonight. ;-)

by Beth on August 11, 2009 at 2:51 pm. #

I’ve read The Hourglass Door and I rather liked it. I just bought Becca’s book this weekend and will be starting it right away! Great reviews, Kim! I’m exicted to see what else you have in store!

by L.T. Elliot on August 11, 2009 at 3:08 pm. #

I won Bright Blue Miracle a while ago, but haven’t had a chance to read it! I better get on that.

by Kristina P. on August 11, 2009 at 3:20 pm. #

Off to see if Barnes and Noble has either of these books. I’m all about YA fiction. 99% of the time it’s cleaner than the fiction written for us “adults”.
Besides, I’ve decided not to grow up. Being an adult isn’t all the fun and games I thought it would be…
Oh, and I sold all my Twilight books on eBay and actually made some money. I know I can’t keep my daughter from reading them, but I don’t want her to have access to them in our home… ya know?

by Melissa on August 11, 2009 at 3:35 pm. #

Wow. Just wow. Thanks, kim, for the kind words – about the book, and about our friendship. You’re a dear.

I like “Hourglass Door” lots – and I’ve had to remind my daughter and her cousin that Ms. Meyer didn’t invent the “mysterious stranger” character type! Good stuff, that hot italian mystery man.

by Becca on August 11, 2009 at 7:07 pm. #

Thank you! I’m always trying to find books I can enjoy with my 13-year-old stepdaughter.

by VirtualSprite on August 11, 2009 at 7:48 pm. #

Great post. I read a lot of YA fiction…for the same reason. But also because it remains one of my favorite genres even now that I’m in my forties. I love a good coming-of-age story!

Thanks for these recommendations. It sounds like I’ll enjoy them both, but especially the first one. And, being a designer, I have to add that I love the cover too!

by charrette on August 11, 2009 at 9:21 pm. #

Yeah, I read Bright Blue Miracle and really enjoyed it and The Hourglass Door is in my queue, too.

by Melanie J on August 12, 2009 at 7:41 am. #

I’m off to get both of these at my library. . .if I can.

I gave away my Twilight book at a white elephant gift exchange. I asked my daughter to wait until she is 14 at least and then have us read it/them together.

Love me some good books!

by Eowyn on August 12, 2009 at 8:38 am. #

Oh yes, I love young adult fiction too. Some times it gets a little romantic, but not sickeningly so and not soft porn like adult fiction often does. Thanks for the recommendations :)

by Susan B. on August 12, 2009 at 8:58 am. #

I will definitely be getting a copy of The Hour Glass Door.

by Jaina on August 12, 2009 at 2:07 pm. #

Leave your comment

Not published.

If you have one.

CommentLuv Enabled